The Buffalo Bills face a pivotal decision as running back James Cook, a two-time Pro Bowler, seeks a contract extension reportedly valued at $15 million per year. With Josh Allen’s Super Bowl window open, GM Brandon Beane must weigh whether Cook’s dynamic play justifies a top-tier salary in a devalued running back market.
Cook’s 2024 season was stellar, leading the NFL with 16 rushing touchdowns and surpassing 1,000 rushing yards for the second straight year. His 44 receptions for 445 yards in 2023 showcased his dual-threat ability, making him a cornerstone of Sean McDermott’s offense. Yet, stalled negotiations have sparked trade rumors.
“Cook is a game-changer, but $15 million for an RB is steep,” said ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler. “The Bills love his versatility, but the market says RBs aren’t worth that much anymore.”
The running back market has cooled, with only Christian McCaffrey ($19 million/year) and Alvin Kamara ($15 million) commanding elite salaries. Cook’s $15 million demand would rank him second among RBs, above Saquon Barkley ($12.5 million). Critics argue Ray Davis and Ty Johnson could fill the void for less.
“Paying Cook that much with Davis waiting is risky,” tweeted BillsMafia fan @BuffaloFanatic. “We need cap space for a WR or safety to beat the Chiefs.”
Cook’s supporters highlight his youth (25) and durability, playing all 17 games in 2024. His 4.7 yards-per-carry average and knack for explosive plays complement Allen’s deep passing. However, Cook’s struggles in pass protection and third-down situations limit his value compared to all-purpose backs like Kamara.
The Bills’ financial situation complicates matters. With a projected $12.6 million cap overage in 2025, signing Cook could force cuts or restructures, especially after adding Joey Bosa and James Bradberry. Trading Cook for draft picks or a receiver like Tyreek Hill, as rumored, remains an option.
As the offseason unfolds, Beane must balance Cook’s undeniable talent against market trends and team needs. X debates rage, with #PayCook trending, but the question lingers: can Buffalo afford to lock up their star back? Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp for updates.
