A former Buffalo Bills safety, revered as a 2022 All-Pro and a cornerstone of the team’s defense, has retired at 35, ending a 12-year NFL journey. A triceps tear suffered in 2024 with his new team proved too much, prompting an emotional farewell that has Bills Mafia reflecting on a golden era.
The star, who anchored Buffalo’s secondary from 2017 to 2023, was Jordan Poyer, a seventh-round pick by the Eagles in 2013. He delivered 22 interceptions, 11 sacks, and 682 tackles across 101 games, earning All-Pro honors in 2022 with four interceptions and 101 tackles alongside Josh Allen.
“This city shaped my career,” Poyer told The Buffalo News’ Ryan O’Halloran. “Bills Mafia’s passion fueled every tackle, especially through my final injury.”
Poyer’s tenure ended in March 2024 when the Bills cut him to save $5.7 million in cap space, a decision that stunned fans. He signed a one-year, $2 million deal with the Miami Dolphins but tore his triceps in Week 8, limiting him to seven games and 41 tackles in 2024.
“He was Buffalo’s heartbeat,” said NFL Network’s Bucky Brooks. “Poyer’s retirement leaves a legacy that Bills Mafia will cherish forever.”
The triceps tear, requiring extensive surgery, followed years of shoulder and knee issues. At 35, Poyer chose family and health over a grueling recovery, retiring with gratitude. Fans poured out tributes, recalling his game-sealing interception against Patrick Mahomes in 2021 that ignited Highmark Stadium.
Brandon Beane hailed Poyer’s impact, noting his leadership shaped safeties like Justin Simmons and Damar Hamlin. James Cook’s ongoing contract saga, with a $15 million demand unmet, mirrors the cap constraints that forced Poyer’s exit, underscoring tough roster choices.
As the 2025 NFL Draft concludes, Poyer’s retirement marks the end of an era for the Bills. His grit and Bills Mafia bond will resonate, inspiring Allen’s Super Bowl pursuit. Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp for updates.
