PITTSBURGH -- The Pittsburgh Steelers are reportedly considering a seismic shift in their coaching ranks, with whispers that Jon Gruden, a Super Bowl-winning coach, could replace Mike Tomlin, sources told ESPN on May 4, 2025. The news has stunned Steelers Nation, as Tomlin, the NFL’s longest-tenured coach, faces scrutiny after a late-season collapse.
Tomlin, who signed a three-year extension through 2027, led Pittsburgh to a 10-7 record in 2024 but faltered with five straight losses, ending in a Wild Card loss to Buffalo. Despite his 183-107-2 regular-season record and Super Bowl XLIII title, some fans and analysts question his postseason success, fueling speculation about a change.
Gruden, 61, is a polarizing figure. He coached the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to a Super Bowl XXXVII victory in 2002, where Tomlin served as his defensive backs coach. However, Gruden’s 2021 resignation from the Las Vegas Raiders after leaked emails containing offensive language has cast a shadow over his return.
A source close to the Steelers’ front office hinted at owner Art Rooney II exploring Gruden as a high-profile successor. “Jon’s a proven winner with ties to Mike,” the source said. “His offensive expertise could spark a stagnant unit.” Pittsburgh ranked 24th in passing yards (186.1 per game) in 2024, a sore spot for Tomlin’s tenure.
Gruden’s potential role has sparked debate. His 117-112 NFL record includes two division titles, but critics point to his lackluster Raiders stint (22-31 from 2018-2021). Supporters argue his quarterback acumen could elevate Mason Rudolph or rookie Will Howard, addressing Pittsburgh’s QB1 void.
Fans on X are divided. “Gruden over Tomlin? That’s a downgrade,” one user posted, while another wrote, “Jon’s offense could unlock DK Metcalf!” The Steelers’ recent additions, like Za’Darius Smith and Stephon Gilmore, suggest an all-in push, but a coaching change would be a franchise-altering gamble.
Tomlin, a “player’s coach” known for fostering loyalty, remains defiant. “I’m focused on 2025,” he told reporters, sidestepping Gruden rumors. His 18-year streak of non-losing seasons is unmatched, making his potential exit a shock.
As the Steelers prepare for OTAs, the Gruden buzz looms large. Will Pittsburgh stick with Tomlin’s stability or roll the dice on Gruden’s volatile brilliance? In the AFC North, where margins are razor-thin, the decision could redefine the Steelers’ future.
